Lakhani, Chordiya, Biyani, Mahajan, and Lakhani: Profile of Intentional and Iatrogenic skin afflictions: An observational study


Introduction

Intentional skin afflictions may occur due to skin branding, tattooing, body piercing and artistic scarifications. Skin branding is type of intervention done by faith healer for relief of pain or for purpose of healing or treating a medical disorder. Intentional skin afflictions are done for the purpose of body art which can be tattooing, body piercing and/or artistic scarifications. Iatrogenic skin afflictions like operative scar which can result into hypertrophic scar and keloid formation. Seeking treatment and intervention of past skin afflictions is one of the usual dermatology practice. These form of skin afflictions may have various consequences including ethical, as it may have done in past without their knowledge or without prior information of medical consequences. Psychosocial domain before and after such afflictions is worth noting as it may have bearing on subsequent medical management.1

Skin branding is a process affliction of skin with iron or wooden rod which creates third degree burns and may result in permanent scars which is difficult to be treated. 2, 3 This traditional practice is result of cultural misbelieves and is used for various systemic and local conditions by faith healers in developing countries including India. 3, 4 Skin branding not only is practiced in adults but also in children. 5, 6 Its use in current times reflects insufficient impact of modern health services on traditional practice which has medical, ethical and psychosocial consequences and can be cause of delay in treatment. 4, 5, 6

Cutaneous scarring, not yet fully understood healing process, is due to fibroblastic tissue replacing normal skin tissue.7 Normal visible incision scar, hypertrophic scar and keloids can result in physical and psychosocial sequelae and may be stigmatizing. Keloids which are elevated scars, spreading beyond the original skin afflicted sites can occur due to cutaneous injury and irritation, including, surgery, vaccination and skin piercing. 7, 8, 9

In modern times, body decoration practices includes tattooing, body piercing, body branding and scarification has grown fast. Such a study, done to impart scientific knowledge on the risk involved in such practices related to body art has become imperative. 10, 11.

Materials and Methods

An observational study was carried out at teaching hospital. Consecutive 36 subjects who had Intentional and/or Iatrogenic skin afflictions seeking medical advice for such affliction and/ or had medical conditions associated with such affliction were included in the study. A research question for this study was “Why and for what consequences do subjects having Intentional/ Iatrogenic skin afflictions seek scientific medical advice?” These cases were included from dermatology and general medicine departments of teaching and university affiliated hospital. Quantitative as well as Qualitative data analysis was done.

Results

A total of 36 patients were included in the study of which 20 were male and 16 female. The average age of the patients was 35.2 ± 14.2 years and the age range was between 8 and 67 years. Skin branding was present in 6 adult patients, 5 were males and 1 female. 12 patients had come for tattoo consultation for removal or seeking for conservative therapy, 6 for body piercing sequelae , 7 for Keloids, and 5 for hypertrophic Scars.(Table 1)

Table 1

Profile of of Intentional and Iatrogenic skin afflictions (n=36)

Skin disorder

Male

Females

Total Number of Subjects

Skin branding

5

1

6

Tattoo

6

6

12

Body piercing

2

4

6

Keloids

5

2

7

Hypertrophic scars

2

3

5

Total

20

16

36

Out of 6 skin branding cases, 5 patients had come primarily for medical treatment while 1 patient had branding mark of childhood which was cosmetic concern and for that reason he visited the dermatology department. One patient of alcoholic cirrhosis had undergone branding in the course of his treatment for gynecomastia which could have been due to his medical condition of cirrhosis of liver and /or his drug spironolactone which he was taking. All other subjects had come primarily for dermatology consultation for seeking either interventions and /or conservative management. All these patients were interviewed for reasons of seeking medical advice. Quantitative as well as qualitative narrative analysis was done for all the subjects to find out reasons for seeking medical advice which is documented in Table 2 and Figure 1, Figure 2, Figure 3, of those who had skin branding and Table 3 and Figure 4, Figure 5, Figure 6 of other cases.

Table 2

Reasons for consultation and their consequences in 6 subjects having skin branding.

S.No

Reason

Narrative

Remarks

1.

Ascites and Cirrhosis with Umbilical Hernia

Branding did not help and so came for further treatment

Delay in treatment

2.

Ascites, and Alcoholic Cirrhosis with Gynecomastia

For Gynecomastia

It may be due cirrhosis of liver and drug spironolactone

3.

Splenomegaly in case of sickle cell anaemia

Had faith in such healing technique/Earlier other tribal subject had beneficial effect

In a reference case spleen regression in a case which was referred may have been due to splenic infarct

4 and 5.

Chronic abdominal pain

Had relief of pain for some time

Counter irritation effect of third degree burns in skin Branding may cause temporary pain relief. 2 Finding out cause of chronic abdominal pain is essential.

6.

Unknown cause of skin branding in childhood

Want to get rid of scar.

Skin branding is performed in children also.

Table 3

Reasons for consultation and their consequences in Intentional and Iatrogenic skin afflictions (N=30)

Skin Disorder

Reason

Tattoo(12)

Tattoo regrets (6),Army tattoo Policy (2) Requirement for job procurement(1), Relationship Conflicts (2), Disapproval from Peers(1)

Body piercing (6)

Parental disapproval *(1), Cosmetic* (4),Surgical (1)

Keloids(7)+ hypertrophic Scar(5)

Cosmetic* (6) fear of extension of cancer in scar tissue(1) pruritus at the affected site (3)

Figure 1

Patient having skin branding marks on lateral aspects of abdomen and over umbilicus

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/0e28b07c-887a-4341-93e4-458ab15d031eimage1.png
Figure 2

patient having circular skin branding mark around umbilicus having huge splenomegaly

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/0e28b07c-887a-4341-93e4-458ab15d031eimage2.png
Figure 3

Patient having circular skin branding mark around umbilicus and a linear branding mark below umbilicus and having ascites and umbilical hernia

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/0e28b07c-887a-4341-93e4-458ab15d031eimage3.png

Figure 4

Keloidal scars

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/bb033d2a-be4d-43a0-b733-06b39ce2f50e/image/1327ee8e-cbb1-4d61-acbe-dec431c0330f-uimage.png

Figure 5

Keloidal scars

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/bb033d2a-be4d-43a0-b733-06b39ce2f50e/image/7caf1339-2aef-4993-8d92-92fc7cc70f86-uimage.png

Figure 6

Partly treated tattoo mark

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/bb033d2a-be4d-43a0-b733-06b39ce2f50e/image/3b169430-eb40-4a0c-a261-219c6eb33e8f-uimage.png

Discussion

Study center involves subjects coming to the hospital from rural as well as urban population of Gujarat and also from central and western India which is bordering Gujarat. Young university students from our own campus also seek dermatological and cosmetic consultation. This study was intended to know the profile of dermatological, medical and psychosocial consequences of some rituals and body art intentional skin affliction activity like body piercing and tattooing. Traditional healing practice like body branding which is also not unusual in clinical practice in India can have medical and psychosocial issues.3, 4, 5, 6

History of skin branding relates to “African American slave” era. Description of oppressed person being identified by branding scar present on the body; is available.12 Marks of skin branding was also used as a symbol to signify membership of particular organization.12 This traditional practice was used by ancient healers for pain relief and also in various chronic ailments. It is believed that it works on counter-irritation theory.2

One of the medical consequences we found in this study was delay in diagnosis of and its subsequent management of the medical condition. Skin branding is advocated as a result of belief system in which both healer and subject feels that it works. Many such interventions may give false hope in untreatable condition. It may cause further harm and wasting of golden hours of treating time in many critically ill conditions as was reported in a case in 1982; having tuberculous meningitis and disseminated tuberculosis having 106 branding marks all over his body.4 Skin branding is also reported being done in illness like tuberculosis, chronic peripheral neuropathy and various gastrointestinal, hepatobilliary and abdominal conditions.6, 13 Ugly scars inflicted in childhood may cause concern in future to a young adult as it may not appear aesthetic, which happened in one of our cases. Secondary infection following branding could result from disruption of the skin barrier .In some cases this secondary infection may not be limited to the skin and may involve deeper structures too. Shah ad et al reported a case of bacterial peritonitis due to E.Coli following skin branding leading to decompensated cirrhosis.2

The branding sites also could lead to formation of hypertrophic scars and keloids. Keloids are extensive growth of scar tissue beyond the border of the original wound and are more symptomatic than hypertrophic scars. According to Santosh et al, keloids are 15 times more likely to develop in pigmented races as compared to whites as there is a genetic predisposition to formation of keloids in pigmented races.14 Keloid formation was a significant problem in our subset of patients as well. Keloids also tend to be far more difficult to treat as compared to hypertrophic scars. 15 Long standing cases of scars can also rarely have malignant potential which was a concern of one of our cases who had hypertrophic scar after radical mastectomy. 16, 17 Patients having keloids and hypertrophic scars comes to dermatologist for demand for local application cream, intralesional conservative intervention by 5-Fluorouracil/steroid or for laser and surgical management. 18, 19

Psychosocial consequences of subjects who came for intervention and advice regarding unwanted tattoo marks and body piercing were conspicuous. Tattoo regrets, Army tattoo Policy, Requirement for job procurement, Relationship Conflicts, Disapproval from Peers, Self disapproval, Body image problems; Parental disapproval and others were the reasons for dermatological treatment. Some of the subject wanted the tattoo removal in a single appointment and immediate as it hindered their job prospects. Dermatologist dealing with tattooed patients should understand, communicate and counsel about this skin affliction which has psychosocial consequences. 1, 20 Medical and infectious complications are also ascribed to all intentional and iatrogenic skin afflictions. 21, 22

Conclusion

Many patients especially in rural India, consider skin branding as a mode of therapy for acute and chronic ailments which may lead to delay in diagnosis and treatment. Intentional and Iatrogenic skin afflictions like tattoo, body piercing, keloids and hypertrophic scars can lead to a variety of issues including psychosocial, ethical, moral, job related and personal. These issues are often overlooked and need further interrogation. Clinicians should take utmost care to treat and manage skin afflictions to achieve the best possible cosmesis. However due care should also be given to the psychological aspects of such skin afflictions so that the holistic well being of the patients can be achieved.

Source of Funding

No financial support was received for the work within this manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest

There are no conflicts of interest.

References

1 

H Roggenkamp A Nicholls JM Pierre Tattoos as a window to the psyche: How talking about skin art can inform psychiatric practiceWorld J Psychiatry2017731485810.5498/wjp.v7.i3.148

2 

S Raza K Mahmood A Hakeem S Polsky A Haemel S Rai Adverse clinical sequelae after skin branding: a case seriesJ Med Case Rep2009312510.1186/1752-1947-3-25

3 

S Mahant CM Reddy S Mahant MP Singh Hot iron rods branding, its complications: Still continue in central IndiaCHRISMED J Health Res 201744264710.4103/2348-3334.216463

4 

J.D. Lakhani K.J. Pathak N Parikh P.V. Kotecha Branding Still a "Treatment" in Rural IndiaLancet1982320829015210.1016/s0140-6736(82)91114-x

5 

P V Varma Chaitanya H Shrikiran M Suneel A Karthick Skin branding in Indian children: A still prevaling superstition in the modern eraWeb Med Central Paediatr 201231WMC002828

6 

S Rathi R Gupta Branding - A Harmful PracticeIndian Pediatr2015521645

7 

S Al-Shaqsi T Al-Bulushi Cutaneous Scar Prevention and Management: Overview of current therapiesSultan Qaboos Univ Med J2016161e3810.18295/squmj.2016.16.01.002

8 

A Bayat DA McGrouther MW Ferguson Skin scarringBMJ20033267380889210.1136/bmj.326.7380.88

9 

PB Olaitan Keloids: Assessment of effects and psychosocial- impacts on subjects in a black African populationIndian J Dermatol, Venereol Leprol20097543687210.4103/0378-6323.53132

10 

A Quaranta C Napoli F Fasano C Montagna G Caggiano MT Montagna Body piercing and tattoos: a survey on young adults' knowledge of the risks and practices in body artBMC Public Health201111177410.1186/1471-2458-11-774

11 

L M Koenig M Carnes Body piercing medical concerns with cutting-edge fashionJ Gen Intern Med199914637985

12 

LJ Hoenig The Branding of African American SlavesArch Dermatol2012148227110.1001/archdermatol.2011.2683

13 

S I John A Balekuduru U Zachariah C E Eapen G Chandy Branding to treat jaundice in IndiaTrop Gastroenterol20093042412

14 

S Hunasgi A Koneru M Vanishree R Shamala Keloid: A case report and review of pathophysiology and differences between keloid and hypertrophic scarsJ Oral Maxillofac Pathol20131711162010.4103/0973-029x.110701

15 

AP Sclafani L Gordon M Chadha T Romo Prevention of Earlobe Keloid Recurrence with Postoperative Corticosteroid Injections Versus Radiation Therapy A Randomized, Prospective Study and Review of the LiteratureDermatol Surg19962265697410.1111/j.1524-4725.1996.tb00376.x

16 

A Majumder S Srivastava P Ranjan Squamous cell carcinoma arising in a keloid scarMed J Armed Forces India2019752222410.1016/j.mjafi.2018.07.018

17 

N Yu X Long JR Lujan-Hernandez K Z Hassan M Bai Y Wang Marjolin’s ulcer: a preventable malignancy arising from scarsWorld J Surg Oncol201311131310.1186/1477-7819-11-313

18 

NG Rabey SJ Goldie RD Price 5-Fluorouracil for keloid scarsCochrane Database Sys Rev20172017910.1002/14651858.cd012792

19 

MM Shah AC Shah KR Ninama RS Mahajan FE Bilimoria Efficacy of intralesional 5 Fluorouracil, triamcinolone acetonide and CO2 laser for treatment of keloids and hypertrophic scars- A comparative studyJ Integrated Health Sci2014223610.4103/2347-6486.239545

20 

A Stirn A Hinz Tattoos, body piercings, and self-injury: Is there a connection? Investigations on a core group of participants practicing body modificationPsychotherapy Res20081833263310.1080/10503300701506938

21 

D I Meltzer Complications of body piercingAm Fam Physician20057210202994

22 

SS Tweeten LS Rickman Infectious Complications of Body PiercingClin Infect Dis19982637354010.1086/514586



jats-html.xsl

© This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0). which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 07-04-2021

Accepted : 13-05-2021

Available online : 29-05-2021


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijced.2021.029


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 99

PDF Downloaded: 62